I just had what might be the worst sandwich I've ever tasted. I ended up tossing it in the trash and went next door to Nachomama's instead. The person who took my order seemed more interested in restocking than actually helping me. When I finally ordered a roast beef and cheese sandwich, it arrived cold and way too salty. I suspect the gravy was the problem because I managed only three bites before I couldn’t eat any more. I couldn’t find anyone to talk to about my concerns, so I decided to throw it away and leave. I definitely won’t be coming back; it’s a far cry from the Amighetti's I once loved.
I ordered from this restaurant via Uber Eats, and it was one of the worst dining experiences I've encountered. The spaghetti was dreadful, smothered in an odd orange sauce that tasted like someone had dumped a can of Spaghetti-O's over the noodles, and it was served cold. Additionally, I ordered two meatballs, but they were undercooked and only had a small amount of meat on top. The garlic bread was mediocre at best and also cold. To make matters worse, I decided to try the brownie, which turned out to be stale. I can't believe I spent $40 on this meal! I'm incredibly disappointed!
I recently ordered lunch from this restaurant, and I was thoroughly impressed. The food deserves a solid 5 out of 5! Each bite was delicious and satisfying. The service was also notable, earning a 4 out of 5; the staff was friendly and efficient, making the takeout process smooth. The ambiance, while not experienced in person, still rates a 4, suggesting a welcoming environment if you choose to dine in. I highly recommend trying The Amighetti Special—it's a standout dish that you won’t want to miss!
Our group ordered from Grubhub, and we were disappointed with the portion sizes of the pasta salads and egg salads; they were quite small. I did find the breading on my toasted cheese ravioli enjoyable, but unfortunately, it was primarily just breading. I paid $9 for an 8-piece serving, and if they had been truly delicious, I might have considered the price worthwhile. Sadly, I ended up feeling like I had paid a premium for mostly just breading.
Reserva una mesa ahora
Today, I visited to grab a sandwich, and I was truly impressed by the young person at the register. They were exceptionally polite and patient with a group of elderly women who needed help with the menu and placing their orders. Another young woman came out from the kitchen to assist in managing the line and keeping things running smoothly. The food is excellent, and the staff is outstanding! This place is definitely a gem in St. Louis!
Overall, if you're in the mood for Italian sandwiches, this restaurant is a solid choice. I was particularly impressed with the coleslaw and potato salad. However, the sandwich, much like several others I've had, had difficulty staying together. To be honest, with a bit of time and effort, I think I could make a similar sandwich at home.
This restaurant is an excellent choice for Italian sandwiches. I was especially impressed by the coleslaw and potato salad. However, the sandwich did fall apart, which is a common issue with many others. Honestly, I believe that with some time and effort, I could whip up a similar sandwich at home.
The food is outstanding, and the menu features a broader variety than the restaurant on the hill. While it can get quite crowded at times, it remains manageable. The venue is wheelchair and walker accessible, and there are safety rails in the restrooms.
Reserva una mesa ahora
I waited more than 40 minutes for my order, and I noticed that customers who arrived after me were served and had already left before my meal was ready.
Food: ★★★★★ (5/5)
Service: ★★★★★ (5/5)
Atmosphere: ★★★★☆ (4/5)
I strongly suggest you try the Amighetti Special!
Vinaigrette Italian Dressing (Salad) Bottles
Signature Special Sauce (Sandwich) Bottles
Creamy Italian Dressing (Salad) Bottles
Gran Galleta Con Chispas De Chocolate
Italian Roast Beef And Cheese Whole
Italian Roast Beef And Cheese Half
Simple Ital. Salad Sandwich Whole
Cannoli Con Chispas De Chocolate
Veggie Little Bit Of Italy Whole
Simple Ital. Salad Sandwich Half
