This intimate restaurant with a cute outdoor space seemed perfect for a small birthday gathering with family. Overall the food was decent, we tried the tortellini soup which was REALLY good. All the entrees were good. The flounder my MIL got was pretty small but all other meals were well portioned and came with pasta or side salad. Our waitress attempted to be nice, but I just didn't get a great vibe from her as her answers were short and at times, rude. All other staff were friendly and helpful. I'm glad we tried this restaurant but not sure I'd go back.
I've been here a few times and every time I go it gets better! They don't take reservations so my group of 8 went at 5 PM on a Saturday and didn't have an issue getting seated, but by 5:30/6, every table was taken. We got a few apps which included mozzarella sticks, calamari, zucc sticks. For the main meal I got eggplant rollatini which was SOOOOO GOOD which came with a side of any pasta I wanted. I had leftovers for the next day. Staff is friendly and atmosphere is clean! Thanks!
First time here and had a fabulous lunch. When we first walked in we were professionally greeted by Jose. He was our waiter and he was awesome. The food was delicious and we will be back. Our current italian go to rest. , up the block from us , has such a limited menu and has gotten old. The menu here has better choices and we can't wait to go back to try the other items on the menu. And we felt the prices were not as high as other places that serve you less food.
Lunch was a 2 star experience. The inflated 4.5 star rating is simply inaccurate. Spaghetti and meatballs was really disappointing like ragu out of the jar with overly breaded meatballs. Nothing good to say about it. Chicken marsala also no taste, sauce overly sweet. No way these dishes were prepared by an Italian chef. Bread was good, Caesar salad was good. You can do as good or better with take out from a pizza place.
Reserva una mesa ahora
I have been a customer at this restaurant since they first opened in Queens! It is hands down the best Italian food in New York! Everything is made fresh and the portions are generous. The baked chopped clams are delicious, along with the Chicken Capri and Chicken Sweet Melissa. Carlo and the rest of the staff create a wonderful dining atmosphere that I thoroughly enjoy.
Great celebration at Cara Mia of Seaford! Family birthday celebration with out standing service and the most tasteful delicious meals conveniently located on Merrick Road. Community minded Family owned/operated. We have had many dinners, attended Business meetings celebrations within this restaurant, which is quiet and is the perfect family setting.
The staff is great helpful and friendly. The food is wonderful. One of the best Italian restaurants on the Long Island.The ambiance is great though at times a little noisy.
First time going there and was very impressed. Staff was attentive, food was hot and delicious. Diffently will go again
Reserva una mesa ahora
Will never not order from here all the food is beyond delicious super consistent and have never had a problem 10/10
Always delicious ! The cavatelli and broccoli rabe egg rolls! So good !
Filete De Costilla A La Parrilla
Colas De Langosta A La Parrilla
Spinach Ravioli Portobello
Raviolis De Queso Al Horno
Fettuccini A La Carbonara
Calamari Fritti Arribiata
