Glass Nickel Pizza Co. – Sun Prairie

It's great to see everyone smiling, but my roommate just pointed out that our Halloween night food arrived in terrible condition. Plus, there was no marinara for the cheese sticks, rendering them completely useless. Did someone drop the pizza? And getting a refund in 72 hours is nice, but it’s only partial for my worthless cheese sticks. I really thought things would improve after your move to the new location. I was willing to overlook some issues at your temporary place because I understand how a sudden surge in business can complicate things. But seriously, who is responsible for putting together and delivering this food? It feels like a bunch of amateurs are running the show. I expect a...

• Útil
• Inútil
• Responder

The rating is lower because given the price, I expected the food to be made with a bit more care. The flavor gets a 5, but the crust rates a 2. I always order the cracker-thin crust, which is even thinner than a standard thin crust! The cheeses are good, but the fries are terrible when they arrive. We don’t live far away either. I suspect they’re made before the pizza and just sit there. The salads are generous in size. However, the marinara sauce comes cold and clumpy. The calzones feel like cardboard, as the crust is far too thick. I think I would have been better off going somewhere else.

• Útil
• Inútil
• Responder

We also tried the cinna nugs and really enjoyed them, but we probably wouldn't order them again due to the poor ratio of nugs to icing. There wasn't enough icing to adequately cover all the nugs, even with just a small amount used for dipping—only enough for about a quarter of them. We ended up making our own icing to finish them off. Our order was ready fairly quickly, the food was tasty, the staff was friendly, and the location is very convenient. We will definitely return!

• Útil
• Inútil
• Responder

Excellent pizza! This was my first visit to this restaurant, and it was fantastic, just like I had heard! The crust was delicious, and the vegan cheese option was perfect for my youngest son, who has a dairy allergy.

• Útil
• Inútil
• Responder

I had a large pizza and wings, and there’s so much more on the menu that I can’t wait to try! The staff was fantastic and very friendly. I highly recommend dining here for everyone.

• Útil
• Inútil
• Responder