"It's been more than a decade since I last visited, and unfortunately, the quality has declined. The authentic New York flavor seems to be missing now. On a positive note, the hostess was fantastic."
The slices at Johnny's New York Style Pizza are alright, but I also ordered a chicken and cheese calzone and was extremely disappointed. To start with the appearance, I wish I could upload a photo—it looked like a large, sloppy chunk of bread that was poorly cut. The filling was barely there, and the sauce was bitter and unpleasant. It felt like a child had been messing around in the kitchen. Now I have to spend more money on food elsewhere. Because of this experience, I won’t be returning; I’d rather make the trip to Vinny’s Midtown instead. I hadn’t returned partly because I read comments about how Johnny's New York Style Pizza treats Black customers, and I’m very particular about what I p...
The associates lack customer service. I was placed on hold for 15 minutes for an associate to find a manager. The manager never came to the phone. Another associate picks up the phone and is yelling at another coworker stating, ?This is someone different.You haven?t took his order.? Not only did she not offer to take the order, she places the phone back down. An associate picks upthe phone and says, ?OK? and I repeated it as a question. The associate then hangs up the phone. I used to order here regularly,but this interaction reminded me why I stopped. The pizza is never ready in the time given that the app says your pizza is readyand the customer service is non existent.
Fantastic option in a rapidly growing dining scene. The service is prompt, reminiscent of the good old days, allowing you to sit down, place your order, and savor your meal, or grab a pizza to go. The menu offers plenty of choices, including great daily specials that provide excellent value. Parking can be a bit limited, but there's usually a spot available. Many employees from nearby businesses frequent this place, making it a popular pizza destination, while families appreciate the welcoming and safe atmosphere. Whether you enjoy a slice or a whole pie, you won't be disappointed!
I can't say enough good things about this place. Seven of us ordered three pizzas and were already full, but we ended up ordering another because the pizza is just that good. We tried Johnny’s Italian and Johnny’s White pizza, and the beer selection was great too. They have a booth in the back that seats about 10 people. Fantastic job, Johnny!
Reserva una mesa ahora
I’m giving Johnny’s New York Style Pizza one star because the pepperoni pizza was really good, but I have no idea what happened to my cheese pizza. It was overcooked, dried out, and too crispy—completely terrible. The staff seemed more concerned with my blue cheese sauce than ensuring my pizza was correct from the menu.
Got a small pizza with toppings and i always ask for a crust flavor but it's like they always decide to just ignore that request. It's like they threw the veggies at my pizza like they were getting rid of it. Just annoyed because Marco's does havegood ingredients but it sucks when it's made poorly
Ordered early for carryout. Pizza was ready on time, fresh and correct. The workers were so nice! Very helpful, offered me plates and napkins (I've never been asked that at any other pizza place). Definitely will be back here. Thank y'all for thegreat food and service!
DO NOT eat here these people serve moldy food and their management is contemptible at best. I ordered a pizza with meatballs and shaved parmesan and encountered mold on both items. When I went to get my money back, management did jack all to correct the problem.
Reserva una mesa ahora
One of the men, who I believe is a manager since I've seen him there multiple times, ignored two people waiting in line, including myself, to assist someone who had just walked in. That was very rude.
It's been more than a decade since I last visited, and unfortunately, the quality has declined. The authentic New York flavor seems to be missing now. On a positive note, the hostess was fantastic.
