We typically order the margarita pizza, which we really enjoy. A few months back, we tried the grandma pie and found it to be fantastic. However, our most recent order, which included one margarita pie and one grandma pie, was disappointing. I was looking forward to the slightly doughy yet crispy crust of the grandma pie we loved before, but this time it tasted more like a cracker. I'm not sure if they forgot to add yeast or if something else went awry, but it was almost inedible. I don't want to be too harsh on the restaurant since we've had great pizza here in the past; I just wanted to share our experience regarding the inconsistency.
We usually get a margarita pizza and it is good. We got a grandma pie a few months ago and that was great. Our recent order of one margarita pie and one grandma pie was not so good. I was looking forward to the slightly doughy but still crispy crust ofthe grandma pizza like we had in the past but this pizza looked and felt more like a cracker. Not sure if they forgot to addyeast or what happened but was barely edible. I am not trying to bash this place as the pizza can be very good here i just wantto let people know the inconsistency we experienced.
This was my second time visiting the restaurant, and we opted for a few plain slices as well as a grandma slice. The pizza was outstanding! The customer service was excellent as well. I had the pleasure of meeting the owner at the register, and he was genuinely humble and easy to converse with. His openness and honesty are rare qualities to find. The prices are reasonable, the food is delicious, and the service is exceptional. I'm confident that this will become a regular pizza spot for me in Metuchen. I highly recommend giving them a try!
Don't miss the chance to visit this restaurant! The margarita and grandma slices are among the best I've ever had in New Jersey. They serve an authentic New York-style pizza slice that is simply amazing. I also sampled the fettuccine Alfredo, which was delicious—packed with flavor without being too heavy. I would give it a perfect 10/10 and will definitely return. The owner, Lenny, is very welcoming too. There are a few tables for indoor seating and a couple of small tables outside.
Reserva una mesa ahora
Incredible New York-style pizza! I absolutely love their Buffalo and Barbecue pizzas, as well as their chicken Alfredo pasta. Everything else I've tried has been equally delicious. The spinach wheels are cooked to perfection, which is a big plus for me. Their vegetable slice is fantastic as well! As for the staff at the pizzeria, their service is outstanding!
You absolutely have to try this place! I’ve been here multiple times, and the pizza is always outstanding. They masterfully balance the sauce and cheese, and the crust is thin but sturdy—definitely no sogginess. If Portnoy were to come here, I bet he would give it a rating somewhere between 8.4 and 8.7.
I finally gave this place a try, and it exceeded all my expectations. The thin crust pizza was outstanding, and I can’t wait to come back and try more dishes from the menu. Highly recommended! Food: 5/5, Service: 5/5, Atmosphere: 5/5.
I've found my new favorite pizza spot! My top recommendations are the buffalo chicken, margherita, and plain cheese pizzas, in that order. The restaurant is impeccably clean too. Well done, L&L! I'll definitely return.
Reserva una mesa ahora
The atmosphere at L L Pizza Pasta New York Style is extremely inviting, and the exceptional service made my experience even better. I would give the food, service, and ambiance all a perfect 5 out of 5.
L L Pizza Pasta New York Style offers incredible New York-style pizza! It’s our top choice in the area, and their menu is definitely worth exploring.
