Excellent birthday dinner. Visited with a reservation at 7pm on 9/9/23. Waiter did not introduce himself (it was a very busy night), but I want to thank him for his excellent service!!! Tony (I assume) seated us and wished us a good evening when we left. Kind, attentive, and respectful of not being overbearing, the service was perfect. The Chicken Rittoli with pesto was delicious! Perfectly cooked chicken and housemate pesto was so fresh. My house salad with house Italian dressing, and my spouse's wedding soup, we're both great starters to the mean. Spouse order a Chicken Parmasean, which instantly became his top ever Chicken Parm dish he's ordered. Waiter went out of his way to find us a ha...
We came into town to meet some friends who were also from out of town. Tony’s was recommended to us by the owner of the AirBnB we were in. It’s a little bit of a nicer place, we were clearly underdressed walking with hoodies and jeans on (we would have dressed a little nicer had we known. Everyone else was dressed up a little bit) but we were treated no differently. Service was incredible, food was incredible, and drinks were good. We feel like we got solid value for the price as well. Would definitely return here
The food was good. We had an appetizer of sausage and peppers which is definitely a strong recommendation. The atmosphere was like a traditional Italian restaurant. The fall was in the service. We had told the waitress that we needed to be out by 7 as we were going to a show. The food took forever to get to the table to the point that we had to get up and find our waitress to get our bill at 715. It was a service failure but we had a good time.
The restaurant feels very classy, with a fine dining experience. Jeff was my server, and he was the nicest guy, checking if I needed refills and making sure I was taken care of. And the food was simply divine! Wedding soup, creamy chicken and tortelloni carbonara, and the lightest and most delicious limoncello cake for dessert. Very satisfied and happy!
Reserva una mesa ahora
Absolutely outstanding establishment! I had the basil pesto tortellini when I say it's the best I've ever had, it's not said lightly! I am very picky but this place hit the flavor price spot. 10383489 10 times would recommend!
We love this place food is awesome, service was excellent, and Tony greeted us on the way out. I personally had the lasagna and eggplant both were amazing. Lots of off street parking in the back.
Huge portions! I got the chicken parm and it was perfect. Wouldn’t change a thing. Also their tiramisu was incredibly soft and moist. Top quality food in a very cute indoor setting.
What a wonderful dinner at Tony’s for my mothers 81st birthday celebration. One of the oldest independent restaurants in Columbus and a true gym.
Reserva una mesa ahora
Love this place. Tucked away little gem. Our waitress was a little off on service this time but otherwise a solid experience.
As a Scilian, this was some of the better Italian food I’ve gotten to try at a restaurant. Great service too.
Veal Piccata (Light, Not Too Filling)
Insalata De Pesce (Seafood Saldad)
Homemade Carrot Cake With Raisins
Anitaâ Grilled Cheese Sandwich
Alla Casino Linguini (Sausage)
Tony's Pesto Chicken Sandwich
Ameretto Chocolate Cheesecake
Spinach And Cheese Cannelloni
Veal And Prosciutto Capellini
Farfalle (Bow Tie) Primavera
