Formaggio's Pie Shack

We tried her on our pizza tour! We are so glad we did! Amazing pizza...both deep dish and thin crust.Out of 5 stars this is how we feel about the pizza.CrustHow did it taste and was it easy to wrangle?4.5 bothSauceHow likely would you be to eat this with a spoon?4.5CheeseWas there too much or too little cheese? Was it gross when it cooled down?5Toppings RatioWas there enough of everything? Was anything too overpowering?5ValueIs this a pizza you could afford to make a habit?3.5CharismaThis is how all of the above comes together, and can include the restaurant and ambiance.5Total RatingHow does this pizza compare to my favourite in the world?4.5My daughter and husband also tried the stuffed pi...

• Útil
• Inútil
• Responder

One of the best pizza places in the city. If you like cheese this is the place to go; their deep dish feels like I'm carrying a toddler home with the weight of the pizza, I love the fact they offer 3 different tomato sauces too so you can change it up each time with regular, sweet or spicy pair it with toppings that are complimented by each sauce. I personally really liked the pairing of salty meats with the sweet sauce but the spicy is great once in a while too for the subtle little kick it adds. Like any good place, they are kind of expensive but you certainly get what you pay for.

• Útil
• Inútil
• Responder

There is no reason this place shouldn't be filled every day! The food was simple and delicious. I got a burger and fries. Burger was juicy and flavourful, the fries were crispy and salty. Just great. Service was great and the prices were unbelievable!! Haven't had a better restaurant experience since before COVID!Kid-friendliness: Kids meals, $6. Nuff said!!

• Útil
• Inútil
• Responder

Got to the restaurant at 8:30 on a Wednesday night with 8 guys. We were told the kitchen is closed and that they can only serve us drinks. It was our first time back after the old bar closed which also wasn't great. We really wanted to give this a chance. First and last time back. Missed opportunity for the new owners.

• Útil
• Inútil
• Responder

My goodness, I went 3 weeks ago and I still can’t stop thinking about the deep dish pizza or the garlic bread. Sooooooo goood!!!!Kid-friendliness: Took my 7 and 13 year old who were given full colouring books and a massive bucket of crayons. They loved it.

• Útil
• Inútil
• Responder