As a new customer I placed a modest custom order for a difficult to source fish just to see how I liked the place. The girl who took my order was delightful and explained the process. I got a call when my order was ready right on schedule from another very pleasant lady. I was offered choices on fish preparation, but I opted out for the whole fish so that I can judge the quality of the product for myself. When I showed up I was greeted warmly by the staff. I was also pleasantly surprised that the fish I got was sourced from the premium European region, and loved getting to know more about the business from Vince who works in the store.The total I paid for this sample order was under $20, but...
I feel incredibly fortunate to live in Wyckoff, just a stone's throw away from Pete’s. As a parent of two young boys, I appreciate that when they’re not preoccupied, one of the staff members—usually Vinnie—will come out to let them interact with the lobsters! This restaurant is truly special when it comes to seafood; when they claim that their fish is fresh, they really mean it! If you’re looking for suggestions, their knowledgeable staff can offer great advice on how to prepare your selections. Don’t miss out on their prepared foods—the grilled salmon is a must-try, and their mixed salads are always a hit. It’s a local gem and a favorite for families who enjoy seafood. Give this place a try...
Great displays! Seafood looks and smells fresh! Only issue is sales people use same glove to accept payment and touch food! When touching cash and/or register that is not sanitary.. Please consider changing gloves or having one person collect payment. Thanks
The staff is friendly and knowledgeable. Please note that they only accept cash, but there is an ATM available in the store for your convenience.
Reserva una mesa ahora
I drove an hour to visit this fish market, and I won't be returning. The person at the counter was quite rude.
I really appreciate their kindness in cleaning the fish I caught while fishing. It was fantastic! Thank you!
The selections are always fresh, and the service is excellent! Just remember to bring cash.
Pete's Fish Market is the best place for fresh fish – you can’t go wrong here!
Reserva una mesa ahora
super fresh, great selection, friendly and warm staff
Great place to buy whole fish!
