I requested my meal to be well done, but this is what I received. When I called to express my concern, they responded, "You asked for well done, so it’s going to be burnt." The owner quickly replied that they offered to replace it, which they did, but their attitude was terrible, and they insisted I bring the pizza back. I would have done so without the need to be told. Here's the evidence: it's not just darker – it's burnt. I won’t be returning. I appreciate their quick response, but I hope others consider going to TJ's in Sayreville instead. It's ten times better and has a welcoming family-run atmosphere.
I personally love this place! I rated the service 3 stars, but it’s not due to the staff; they’re just incredibly busy all the time. It can take a little while to get your food, and while there have been a few mistakes, they’ve always been quick to correct them or offer something extra. The workers are fantastic, and the food is great, so keep up the good work!
As for parking, the lot is quite small and shared with another busy store, which can be frustrating, but other than that, everything is fine.
This is unequivocally the best pizza I've ever had. I happened to stop by today and grabbed two slices from the counter: a thin crust buffalo chicken and a thin crust chicken parmesan. Although I rarely find myself in Aberdeen, I would definitely consider driving 30 minutes just to get a pizza from here. The place is very clean, and they have a wide variety of menu options, including pasta and salad. Great food all around!
The Hot Honey Roni pizza and Buffalo Wings with the garlic parmesan dipping sauce were absolutely fantastic! The Nutella-filled Zeppoli were also delightful, generously stuffed with Nutella! I’m a big fan of the chicken Caesar wrap paired with French fries—I order it at least once a month, haha. Both pickup and delivery services have been excellent experiences. The staff is very friendly, too!
Reserva una mesa ahora
This is a fantastic pizza place. They prepare their dough on-site, and the food is excellent, complemented by a wonderful atmosphere. The staff and owners are very friendly. Be sure to try their chicken parmesan stromboli; nearly everything on the menu is delicious!
I have a few suggestions for improvement: the crust should be less crunchy, and the quality of the cheese could be enhanced. There was also too much sauce for my taste, and I would prefer a thicker pizza. I truly hope you can make some changes to improve the pizza.
New York-style pizza features a thin crust loaded with toppings. A good slice should hold its shape when folded. This restaurant excels in that regard, as the cheese and toppings truly shine in every delicious slice.
I really enjoy their pizza; however, it usually arrives cold or at best, lukewarm. I'm not sure if they use a carrier to keep it warm during delivery.
Reserva una mesa ahora
Expensive, but not excessively so; it was a bit oily, but the taste was enjoyable. Otherwise, it would have been a five-star experience.
Amazing pizza and outstanding service! This is our top choice for pizza. My kids enjoy it too!
