For true pizza lovers, Pelham Pizza is a must-visit! While they offer classic options like cheese, buffalo, and margherita, the real excitement is in their unique and amazing flavors you won’t find anywhere else. The crust is incredibly delicious, and their ricotta cheese is simply irresistible! They also have a daily soup menu with at least 5-6 choices to pick from. Pelham Pizza is always busy and finding a table can be a challenge, but be patient – it’s definitely worth the wait. The staff are very friendly and work tirelessly both front and back of house to serve the highest quality pizza right to your table. I couldn’t resist and had to take a bite before snapping pictures!
I'm not sure what's better at this place—the food or the staff. Both are exceptional! The Buffalo chicken slice I had was by far the best I've ever tasted, and the crust was just right. It was strong enough to hold all that chicken without being overly thick. I also ordered a chicken roll, but I couldn't finish it because the slice was so filling. I managed to take two bites before wrapping it up to take home, and it was absolutely delicious! I'm glad I had to catch a train; otherwise, I would have happily eaten the whole thing. The prices were fantastic as well. This is the perfect old-school pizzeria, and now I'm motivated to leave for work a bit earlier just to come here!
I'm not sure what's better at this place—the food or the staff; both are outstanding. That was, without a doubt, the best Buffalo chicken slice I've ever had, and the crust was just right. It was sturdy enough to hold all the chicken but not too thick. I also ordered a chicken roll that I couldn't finish because the slice was so filling. I managed to take two bites before I had to pack it up, and it was absolutely delicious. I’m glad I had to catch a train; otherwise, I would have been stuck trying to eat it all. The prices are fantastic, making it the perfect old-school pizzeria. I’m now inspired to arrive at work a bit earlier just so I can stop by here!
For serious pizza lovers! They offer the usual classics like cheese, buffalo, and margherita, but you absolutely must try their unique flavors—I’ve never seen anything like them before. The crust is incredibly delicious, and the ricotta they use is simply amazing! They also have daily soups, with at least 5-6 options to choose from. The place is often busy and finding a table can be a challenge, but be patient—it’s definitely worth the wait! The staff, both in the front and back of the kitchen, are very friendly and work hard to serve the best quality pizza to your table. Sorry, I couldn’t wait—I took a bite before snapping the pictures!
Reserva una mesa ahora
I had a fantastic pizza experience that reminded me of the good times before COVID. The restaurant has plenty of staff, ensuring that the food comes out quickly. My family loved the cake I brought home, and I was happy with the price I paid—it was a bit less than what I'd typically spend at a place closer to home. A tip: bring a friend with you! Just be aware that parking is limited to the street, and it can be tricky to find a spot, especially at night. There's often a police presence on weekends, so you definitely don’t want to risk double-parking. I’m eager to return to try their pasta!
The pizza here is fantastic, just like I remembered before the pandemic. There’s plenty of staff to ensure that the food comes out quickly. My family loved the pizza I brought home, and I was pleased with the price, which was a bit lower than what I'd typically pay at a place closer to home. A tip: bring someone with you, as street parking is limited. At night, finding a convenient spot can be tricky, and there’s a noticeable police presence on weekend nights, so double parking isn’t a good idea. I'm really looking forward to returning to try the pasta!
I've been a loyal customer of Pelham Pizza for over 20 years, and without question, it's the best pizza in the area. The staff are friendly and welcoming, creating a true neighborhood feel. The food is consistently delicious, and the atmosphere is family-friendly. My kids never want to miss our takeout nights from Pelham Pizza because the quality and service are always top-notch.
The food quality at this place feels more akin to that of a high-end restaurant rather than your average pizza spot. It can be a bit busy and noisy at times, but it's absolutely worth a visit. Their Sicilian slices are outstanding and make for a wonderful dinner choice. Although prices have increased recently, they remain quite reasonable in comparison to other places.
Reserva una mesa ahora
The food quality here is closer to that of an upscale restaurant than a typical pizza place. It can get a bit busy and noisy, but it's definitely worth the visit. The Sicilian slices are excellent, and there are fantastic dinner options as well. Prices have increased recently, like many other establishments, but they’re still reasonable.
I've been coming to Pelham Pizza for over 20 years and without a doubt the best pizza in the area. The staff is amazingly very neighboring and the food is great. Family friendly and always in line with their quality of food and service. All my kids know they can't miss their night with Pelham Pizza.
